City crews slipline trenchless sanitary pipe project in San Antonio
HOBAS Pipe USA starts 2007 with a story about its pipe being used in San Antonio to slipline a deteriorated and leaking sanitary sewer -- without reducing flow capacity -- and with its own crews. City-owned public utility San Antonio Water System now is installing HOBAS centrifugally-cast, fiberglass-reinforced, polymer mortar (CCFRPM) pipe in trenchless projects for utility maintenance around town. After collapse of a 48-inch outfall, SAWS got to put its crews' knowledge to the test...
By Kimberly Paggioli, P.E.
Marketing Manager, HOBAS Pipe USA
SAN ANTONIO, TX, Jan. 3, 2006 -- "We can do that," occurred to the San Antonio Water System (SAWS), and they were right. This city owned public utility now has its own crews installing HOBAS centrifugally-cast, fiberglass-reinforced, polymer mortar (CCFRPM) pipe in trenchless projects in utility maintenance projects around town.
Years of watching contractors was a great learning experience and help from the HOBAS Pipe field service group gave SAWS the confidence to bring some of the work in house and reduce their reliance on local contractors.
Gordon Mahan, SAWS manager of distribution and collection, summed it up, "We saw an opportunity to save time and money and we capitalized on it. We had been considering expanding our work projects to include doing live sliplining ourselves. We had the equipment and the manpower to do it."
A group from SAWS visited the HOBAS Pipe USA factory in Houston, Texas, to watch pipe production and get a better understanding of the product and its use. They also visited a sliplining project in a neighboring city where HOBAS pipes were being installed. Although many feet of HOBAS have been installed in the San Antonio area, this was SAWS' first attempt at sliplining. "For this project, we needed a proven product; we didn't consider products without a proven history," said Dennis Laskowski, Engineer II.
Richard Turkopp, P.E., vice president of engineering at HOBAS Pipe USA, said, "Nationwide during the last 20 years, over 800,000 feet of HOBAS CCFRPM pipes, in diameters from 18 to 110 inches, have been sliplined into deteriorated and leaking sanitary sewers. Hobas pipes' repeated successes in this type of installation have made them the preferred material for large diameter sewer rehab across the country."
After the collapse of a 48-inch outfall, SAWS had the opportunity to put their knowledge to the test. Initially, the failure location was thought to be in an isolated area that included a siphon. Crews made emergency repairs, but a thorough study determined that additional areas south of the collapsed location also needed repair, though not on an emergency basis. "We had a contract to install cured-in-place pipes in the deteriorated areas of the siphon, but wanted a more cost-effective approach to the rest of the line repairs. We decided to take our time and do it right, and do it ourselves," said Mahan.
Laskowski, one of those responsible for the design, voiced some of their pressing concerns, "The failing line was under a roadway adjacent to a cold storage plant where 18-wheelers travel constantly. We were concerned about the structural condition of the pipe due to these heavy traffic loads and the condition of the pipe, which could cause an immediate pipe failure. Sliplining the existing pipe would solve the structural issues, prevent further pipe corrosion and ensure leak free joints. It would also reduce the amount of street cutting and associated downtime the cold storage plant would suffer if the pipe were to be open cut.
"Another reason we considered CCFRPM pipe is the capacity of the line. With the hydraulic characteristics, we wouldn't see any flow reductions from the decreased diameter," Laskowski added. A 42-inch diameter HOBAS pipe was evaluated hydraulically and met the design needs.
SAWS issued an invitation to bid/proposal for 2,666 feet of 42-inch, 82-psi stiffness class, 20-foot joints of bell-spigot pipe. Because of SAWS' positive past experience with HOBAS, the pipe's ability to meet the design criteria and SAWS' confidence in the product for this application, they chose to take bids only on that material.
Easy to Install
The SAWS operations crews began the sliplining process by evaluating the existing line. They videoed the line with remotely controlled camera equipment to assess the pipe condition and look for joint offsets or misalignments that might hamper the sliplining process. The first push was upstream, appeared relatively straight and had been sufficiently cleaned. "Throughout the duration of the project, we were in touch with the HOBAS field service group. They provided us with a lot of information and guidance; they were very knowledgeable," stated Mahan.
Omar Carrasco, field service technician for HOBAS, described the work, "Initially, the installation of the pipe itself didn't set any records for pace, but it was consistent and non-eventful. What more could you ask for a first time? On day one, they installed 10 pipes. Production rates steadily increased and after a few days, the installation crew looked as if they had been doing this for years. By the end of the first run, pipe installation rates were up to five pipes an hour, with the first 1,000-foot run completed in only three days.
"The next run was inserted from the same pit, but downstream. There was one point, close to the end of the second push, where I thought they might have some difficulty, but they (SAWS crews) used sand bags in the pipe to divert water to the annular space, lifting the liner pipe over the obstruction.
"The crew's preparation and knowledge, as well as the pipe's attributes, enabled the rapid installation. The flush joint pipes had exactly the same outside diameter along their length even at the bell ends. This allowed for easy insertion into the host. The inside diameter was also very consistent along its length. The centrifugal casting process produces a dense pipe wall with a high compressive strength that allows for high jacking capacity, even with a relatively thin wall structure. The efficient design allows for an oversized inside diameter, which recovers the most flow capacity."
HOBAS manufactured fittings for the pushing and receiving shaft locations. The T-base systems were either straight or mitered to fit the alignment of the existing sewer. When possible, the fittings were supplied with flush bell and spigot joints that mated perfectly to the bell-spigot joints on the adjacent sliplined reaches. HOBAS also manufactured closure couplings that were utilized to tie in the fiberglass T-base systems.
The reason for the use of the product changes depending on whom you ask. The design engineers required a time proven, structural solution that would be there for years to come. The installation staff wanted a rugged, versatile liner pipe and a pipe manufacturer with a proven history of success.
"We chose sliplining with HOBAS pipes because it seemed very user friendly, and we didn't have to bypass flow. Our concerns with bypassing are not only the cost but the safety," explained Mahan. The gasket-sealed HOBAS pipes allowed installation under live conditions without any disruption to the sewer service.
SAWS crews are pleased with the HOBAS product performance as well as the technical experience of the HOBAS employees. With this project nearing completion, HOBAS looks forward to many more projects in San Antonio.
Houston-based HOBAS Pipe USA (www.hobaspipe.com) manufactures pipe in sizes from 18 inches to 110 inches in pressure and non-pressure classes.
-- "Tunneling Used to Minimize Disruption During Little Walnut Creek Pipeline Projects" (WaterWorld)
-- "Grand Prairie, Texas, installs 10,000 feet of Hobas pipe"
-- "With Wings Overhead, McAllen Airport Airport Sliplines Pipe Under Live Runway" (Industrial WaterWorld)
-- "HOBAS Pipe 'out of sight, out of mind' in Seattle area"