Fate of Nano Waste: Researchers study how to make nanomaterial industry environmentally sustainable
Research into making the emerging nanomaterial industry environmentally sustainable is showing promise in a preliminary engineering study conducted at the Georgia Institute of Technology and Rice University. The researchers were to present their findings at the American Chemical Society national meeting March 16 in San Diego...
ATLANTA, GA, March 16, 2005 -- Research into making the emerging nanomaterial industry environmentally sustainable is showing promise in a preliminary engineering study conducted at the Georgia Institute of Technology and Rice University.
Under the auspices of the Rice University Center for Biological and Environmental Nanotechnology (CBEN) funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF), researchers have been investigating the potential environmental impact of nanomaterial waste. Specifically, they want to know if they can predict the fate and transport of nanomaterial waste in natural systems, and whether nanomaterials will behave the same as common environmental pollutants. In addition, they want to determine if nanomaterials can be treated before they enter the environment to minimize impact.
Previous research provided information on how structures such as fullerenes clump together in water to form larger particles. This study is the first to show what factors affect the size of these aggregate particles.
Researchers picked fullerenes, molecules composed of 60 carbon atoms, as their model carbon-based nanomaterial. Fullerenes have a potentially broad range of applications, including their use in pharmaceuticals, as lubricants, as semiconductors and in energy conversion. Mass commercial production of fullerenes may get under way internationally in just two years.
"This research is providing the information to make practices sustainable when fullerene production comes on line," said John Fortner, a Georgia Tech research scientist and Rice University Ph.D. student. "It's our goal to minimize environmental impact in contrast to the pollution caused in the past by, for example, dry cleaning industry practices.
"It is a new thing to have research funding to look at a material's potential as a pollutant, how to minimize its environmental impact and make the industry sustainable," Fortner added. "It's really the right thing to do. You know, 'An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.'"
Fortner will present findings of the research team March 16 at the American Chemical Society's 229th national meeting in San Diego, Calif. The team includes Joe Hughes, chair of the Georgia Tech School of Civil and Environmental Engineering and a former Rice University professor.
Though much is known about fullerenes, little is known about their fate when released into the environment because they have not been produced on an industrial scale. For now, the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) calls for handling fullerenes in the same way as carbon black, which is similar to graphite and very different in properties from fullerenes ¿ in particular the C60 "buckyball" carbon molecules that Fortner and his colleagues are studying.
"Fullerenes are virtually insoluble in water, yet most biological and environmental systems are based around water," Fortner noted. "Researchers thought fullerenes couldn't be transported by water because they are so hydrophobic. We thought they would simply stick to soil or other organic material. But research shows this is actually not the case. When fullerenes, such as C60, come in contact with water, they form aggregates at the nanoscale. We call it nano-C60."
In their study, Fortner and his colleagues devised several novel applications of imaging techniques to characterize the physical and chemical formation of nano-C60 particles in water mixed with the organic solvent THF. Using cryoTEM (transmission electron microscopy), researchers froze samples of the solution and examined slices of them to determine the effects of various parameters on particle size.
The nano-C60 particles that formed were 20 to 500 nanometers across and retained the same properties as C60 molecules ¿ a determination researchers made using nuclear magnetic resonance imaging. This finding is significant because pure C60 is recoverable, therefore enhancing the promise of sustainable fullerene production practices, Fortner noted. Also, electron and powder diffraction techniques revealed that nano-C60 has a particular crystalline structure. These findings reinforced previous research done elsewhere.
"Our work builds on previous findings in an environmental engineering context," Fortner explained. "We wanted to know about nano-C60 formation under a variety of ambient natural conditions."
Researchers found that changing the pH of the water with which C60 is mixed affected particle size. A higher pH, such as 9, yielded smaller particles, and a lower pH, such as 5, yielded larger particles. Also, the rate at which C60 is mixed with water affected particle size. A slower rate resulted in larger particles, and a faster rate produced smaller ones.
"This research is the first to show control over the particle formation processes based on these parameters," Fortner said.
Researchers also examined the stability of these particles as a function of ion concentration in the water. Because nano-C60 particles rely on a negatively charged surface to remain suspended in water, the presence of elevated concentrations of ions, such as dissolved NaCl (table salt), can render the surface neutral. If that happens, nano-C60 particles sink to the bottom of the solution container and form a solid glob, Fortner explained.
"In the laboratory, scientists typically use de-ionized water, but that's not the case in nature," Fortner said. "At some level, salt is present, even in groundwater. We found that even in water with the normal salt concentration of groundwater, nano-C60 particles still remain suspended for months. However, in simulated sea water, the particles are neutralized and sink in a matter of hours."
Researchers don't yet know the full implications of this finding, Fortner added.
"We've just developed a conceptual model so far, and it doesn't take into account all of the unknowns or heterogeneity found in the environment," Fortner said. "We studied the most controlled situations and got preliminary data."
About the Author: Jane Sanders is a writer with the Research News & Publications Office at Georgia Tech in Atlanta. Images courtesy of John Fortner.
For related articles from Georgia Tech, see:
-- "Protecting Public Spaces from Terror: Systems engineering approach offers new paradigm that stresses prevention"
-- "Environmental Improvement: Ga. county industry, govt. join for unique EMS plan"
Additional information for bottom photo: C60 dissolved in toluene (see vial on left, magenta) does not partition into water (bottom). In the second vial from the left, C60 dissolved in the solvent THF. In the third vial from the left, water is added to the C60/THF solution, resulting in a yellow suspension of C60 nanoparticles (nano-C60). In the third vial from the right, THF can be evaporated, resulting in a water suspension of nano-C60 in only water. The nano-C60 in water (bottom) only very slowly dissolves into organic solvents such as toluene (top) in the second vial from the right. The addition of a mild oxidant drives the fullerenes from the water (bottom) back into the organic phase (top, light magenta) in the vial at the far right.