Environmental groups challenge attempt to degrade streams in Pa. county
PITTSBURGH, PA, July 23, 2009 -- Environmental organizations and local municipalities and businesses submitted reports to the Pennsylvania DEP challenging an attempt by Foundation Mining to downgrade several tributaries to South Fork Tenmile Creek in Greene County...
• Experts' reports show several tributaries to South Fork Tenmile Creek entitled to additional protection
PITTSBURGH, PA, July 23, 2009 -- Yesterday, the Center for Coalfield Justice (CCJ), Mountain Watershed Association (MWA), and Citizens for Pennsylvania's Future (PennFuture), along with other environmental organizations and local municipalities and businesses submitted reports to the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), challenging an attempt by Foundation Mining, L.P. (Foundation), to downgrade several tributaries to South Fork Tenmile Creek in Greene County from High Quality -- Warm Water Fishes to Warm Water Fishes, a status that would permit more pollution to the streams.
In response to the attempt by Foundation, CCJ, MWA, and PennFuture commissioned studies that found not only that the tributaries were entitled to their existing High Quality designation, but that several of the streams were actually entitled to a higher Exceptional Value designation, which would provide them with even more protection than they currently enjoy. A recent determination by DEP providing immediate Exceptional Value protection to several of these streams strongly suggests that studies conducted by DEP were consistent with the studies submitted yesterday.
Krissy Kasserman, Mountain Watershed Association's Youghiogheny Riverkeeper, said, "In attempting to lower the level of protection of our streams, Foundation has thus far succeeded only in raising the level of protection of several of those streams. We hope that the backfiring of this petition discourages other companies from pursuing this misguided strategy in the future."
Terri Davin, community organizer for the Center for Coalfield Justice, said, "These streams have miraculously dodged the bullet of damage from the coal industry, unlike far too many of our streams. I hope our message is loud and clear: attempts to lower the level of protection for our streams will not go unnoticed or unchallenged. Clean water is far too important to our communities."
Brian Glass, staff attorney for PennFuture and counsel to the environmental groups, said, "The legal requirements that must be satisfied to lower the level of protection afforded to streams are intentionally demanding. Less protection is the exception, not the rule. The industry would be better served spending its resources on appropriately protecting our highest quality streams than on lame attempts to circumvent those protections."
On June 9, 2008 Foundation submitted a petition for rulemaking to the Pennsylvania Environmental Quality Board (EQB), an independent board that reviews and approves all of DEP's regulations, asking to downgrade designations of tributaries to South Fork Tenmile Creek in Greene County (including House Run, Hoge Run, and McCourtney Run). DEP has been charged with studying the issue and reporting back to the EQB with its recommendation.
The reports submitted by the environmental groups were performed by Dr. Ben M. Stout, III, Ph. D and Schmid & Company Inc., Consulting Ecologists.
PennFuture is a statewide public interest membership organization that provides at least $2 million in free legal assistance to community and environmental groups each year.
The Mountain Watershed Association is a community-based public interest organization concerned with the conservation, restoration and protection of the Indian Creek Watershed in Fayette and Westmoreland Counties.
The Center for Coalfield Justice was formed as the "Tri-State Citizens Mining Network" in 1994 by a coalition of grassroots groups and individuals concerned about the effects coal mining had on communities and the environment.
Others joining in the submission are Clean Water Action, Friends of Dunkard Creek, Greene County Watershed Alliance, Izaak Walton League, Wheeling Creek Watershed Conservancy, Morgan Township, Morris Township, Waynesburg Borough, West Greene School District, Cornerstone Care, Forever Greene House, Hopkins Store, Red Barn Farm, Rush Funeral Home Inc., Rush Grocery & Video, and White Buck Farm.