Itron issues update on patent infringement litigation court issues order on two outstanding issues
Itron, Inc. has reported that the United States District Court, District of Minnesota, has issued an Order addressing two outstanding issues in the Benghiat patent litigation.
SPOKANE, Wash., June 17, 2003 -- Itron, Inc. has reported that the United States District Court, District of Minnesota, has issued an Order addressing two outstanding issues in the Benghiat patent litigation.
In December 2002, a jury in Minneapolis returned a verdict against Itron and found that Itron's manual entry handheld meter reading devices infringed a patent owned by Ralph Benghiat, an individual. The jury awarded Benghiat damages of $7.4 million and determined that Itron's infringement was willful. Itron recorded a $7.4 million pre-tax charge for the amount of the jury's award in 2002.
The Court subsequently requested briefs from both parties addressing (1) whether and to what extent the Court should award increased damages for the finding of willful infringement and (2) the parties' motions for judgment on the issue of laches. During the trial, Itron filed a motion under the doctrine of laches, claiming that Benghiat waited too long before accusing Itron of infringing his patent and therefore the period for damages should not start until April 1999, the date Benghiat first claimed that Itron's products infringed.
Under the Court's Order dated June 16, 2003, the Court found insufficient evidence to warrant enhanced damages in excess of the jury's award and denied Benghiat's demand for enhanced damages. The Court also denied Itron's motion to shorten the period of damages under the laches doctrine.
The Court Order also specifies that other post-trial motions must be filed within ten days, and responses to post-trial motions must be filed within ten days after that. Final judgment in this matter will be entered after the Court's ruling on post-trial motions.
Itron continues to believe that its products do not infringe the Benghiat patent and may file additional post trial motions, as well as appeal any final judgment by the Court. Appeals of the Court's final judgment must be made within 30 days of the judgment to the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington D.C. Payment of the final judgment award, after the posting of an appropriate bond, would not be due until any appeals have run their course, which we estimate would take approximately 18 to 24 months.
Itron is a technology provider and critical source of knowledge to the global energy and water industries. More than 2,800 utilities worldwide rely on Itron technology to deliver the knowledge they require to optimize the delivery and use of energy and water. Itron delivers value to its clients by providing industry-leading solutions for meter data collection, energy information management, demand side management and response, load forecasting, analysis and consulting services, transmission and distribution system design and optimization, Web-based workforce automation, commercial and industrial customer care and residential energy management.